Self-Hosting Immich vs Google Photos: Complete Comparison
Can Immich really replace Google Photos? A detailed comparison of features, performance, mobile apps, and the migration experience.
immichgoogle-photoscomparisonphotos
Google Photos Strengths
Best AI (face recognition, object detection, natural language search)
Best mobile app UX
Automatic backup (deep OS integration)
Shared libraries and partner sharing
Memories and collages
Free editing tools
Google Lens integration
Immich Strengths
Self-hosted (full data ownership)
No storage limits (limited by your disk)
No compression (store original quality)
Growing AI features
Active development (new features weekly)
No privacy trade-offs
Works with any storage
Feature Comparison
Auto backup: Both (Google is more reliable)
Face recognition: Both (Google is more accurate)
Object detection: Both (Google far ahead)
Natural language search: Both (Google far ahead)
Shared albums: Both
Maps: Both
Memories: Both
Video playback: Both
RAW support: Immich
Original quality storage: Immich
Privacy: Immich (by definition)
The Reality
Google Photos is still better at AI features. Immich is catching up fast and is already good enough for most users. The privacy and ownership benefits make Immich the better choice if you're willing to self-host.
Migration
Google Takeout → import into Immich. The process works but large libraries take time.
Deploy Immich on TinyPod. Run both in parallel while you gain confidence.